Price: $55.00 (15 x 0.05 oz)
Overall Grade: A-
Urban Decay's 15-Year Anniversary Palette seems to be the "most talked about" product at the moment. At first, I was unsure about it but as time went on, it became something that I had to get. I wanted it more for "blogging purposes" in the beginning but after having worked with the palette, I'm falling in love with it more and more every day.
The Packaging: As I mentioned before, I don't like the packaging. To me, it's a hot mess. The lid of the palette is packaged in a smoky mirror material and contains a cool "laser-cut filigree design" along the edges (as described on UD's product page.) The top of the lid contains a purple, jeweled "UD" logo. Inside the lid, there's a huge mirror which is a nice touch. The tray holding the shades is made of a bright purple, mirrored material. And the final touch is a "secret compartment" -the tray holding the eyeshadows is removable therefore revealing the tiny compartment.
While the design is indeed very original, I rather have something more practical. The cons?
- Too heavy
- HIGHLY prone to fingerprints
- The lid is too loose and comes off very easily
- Not ideal for travel
- Too big to store
- The hidden compartment is so small. Sure, there will be room after all the eyeshadows are used up but 1) Who's is going to actually use up all these shades and 2) It'll still be too small and too bulky even if you use up all the eyeshadows. I'd much rather have a jewelry or trinket box that I can store a lot in.
The Product: The palette contains 15 limited edition shades that have never been released before. While some have argued that there are dupes, of all the UD eyeshadows I own (and I only own 2 other palettes -sold the rest of my UD palettes), I don't believe there are any "exact" dupes. Yes, there are bound to be similarities but no exact dupes as again, these are all new shades.
As for the product itself, the color payoff, like most Urban Decay eyeshadows, is excellent. I didn't hit a single "true" dud. I read Christine's review and she mentioned that Tainted "sheered out easily." I guess in a way, it does, but I really didn't have too many problems with that particular shade -it's actually one of my favorites in terms of color. Each shade applies very smoothly (like butter!) and blends fairly easily. However, out of all the shades, I did find Evidence to be slightly chalky and stiff. It didn't feel as smooth as the others but overall, I'd say the quality of the shade is still very good. As for the shade that I liked the least, it would be Blackout. I had to layer it on a few times to get a "true" black and while it is a very good matte black, I do feel like I have other matte blacks that are better.
I've read so many shade descriptions for this palette -here's my take on the shades..
- Midnight Rodeo- Taupe-y brown bronze with a touch of champagne and subtle glitter
- Midnight 15- Frosty pale, "dirty" champagne with a touch of silver shimmer
- Vanilla- Pale yellowed ivory with golden shimmer
- Flow- Frosty light peachy champagne with shimmer
- Chase- Frosty tanned bronze with a touch of gold and shimmer
- Tainted- Slightly warmed, rosy lavender with champagne shimmer
- Junkshow- Bright violet-fuchsia with a touch of violet shimmer
- Omen- Blue-violet with silvery blue shimmer
- Evidence- Deep sea blue with blue shimmer and sheen
- Deep End- Frosty teal with shimmer
- Deeper- Deep bronze with a touch of olive and golden shimmer
- M.I.A.- Deep brown with the slightest touch of plum and copper shimmer
- Ace- Very deep gray with subtle silver shimmer (leans almost blue to me)
- Blackout- Matte black
- Half Truth- Cool deep silvery purple with silvery shimmer
Above (with flash) from left: Midnight Rodeo, Midnight 15, Vanilla, Flow, Chase
Above (with flash) from left: Tainted, Junkshow, Omen, Evidence, Deep End
Above (with flash) from left: Deeper, M.I.A., Ace, Blackout, Half Truth
Overall: This is a great value. At $17 per single (0.05 oz) eyeshadow, you're basically getting 15 full size eyeshadows for the discounted price of $55. Individually, the eyeshadows would cost a grand total of $255 -that's a savings of $200!
The palette contains shades from three categories: neutral shades, bright fun shades, and deeper, smoky shades. This is a palette that could fit individuals of all different tastes. It's a great all-around palette for someone who's just starting out and would like to buy high-end eyeshadows in a variety of different shades. It's also a wonderful palette for any makeup junkie or collector.
The quality is there. The only reason the palette got an "A-" is because of the packaging. Change that and it would definitely be a a solid "A".
Where To Buy: Urban Decay, Sephora (in stores)
This should be coming to other retailers by the end of July/early August