I've heard of people using Extra Virgin Olive Oil as makeup remover for years but I finally tried it myself. It's supposed to remove makeup very well, be very gentle, and not dry out the skin while actually not making it super oily.
I used the olive oil as I would my normal makeup remover. I poured some of the oil onto a cotton pad and used it on my eyes, face, and lips. For everywhere but the eyes, it was fine. For the eyes, it removed everything -even waterproof makeup, but stung my eyes like no other makeup remover ever has. It was so painful that I ended up sticking my face (and eye) under cold running water for about 3 minutes straight.
Maybe it was because I only had the Costco Kirkland brand but I'm never trying this again. However, if you do try it, you should wash your face afterwards since it'll obviously be a bit oily and "greasy." Also, don't say I didn't warn you about the case of crazy burning eyes you may contract.